If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, SheKnows may receive an affiliate commission.
When people hear about a deep berry shade of lipstick, shoppers are either instantly intrigued by it or instantly put off by it. But when it comes to Clinique’s Almost Lipstick in Black Honey, that debate goes right out the window, and nearly every shopper gives a pretty universal, resounding love for the lipstick. In case you don’t know, or are new to the beauty community, Clinique’s Black Honey is one of the most iconic lipsticks of our generation for quite a few reasons. It’s a cult-favorite lipstick that’s considered one of the most wearable, since it was designed to complement every skin tone (and trust us, that theory has been put to the test numerous times). It’s rather lightweight and glossy for a lipstick, but it still has that smooth colorful look to it that lipstick possesses. And it’s so loved that, according to Clinique, seven Black Honey lipsticks are sold each minute globally. However, with a $25 price tag, many want to find cheaper alternatives. While $25 may seem cheap for some, it is quite expensive for many, especially for a lipstick. And for those on that quest to find the perfect look-alike to the Black Honey lipstick, we got you. After searching through Amazon, and searching through so many tick tocks that tried to decipher the best of the best for a look-alike, we found four that are not only super close with a color and consistency match, but they’re all under $10.
Below, check out the best look-alikes to Clinique’s Almost Lipstick in Black Honey.
Amazon Big Deals Day 2024 is taking place on Tuesday, Oct 8, and Wednesday, Oct 9. However, there are already some major deals happening ahead of time, so it’s time to start taking advantage of it all.
-
Catrice Care in Colours Lip Balm in Wild Rebel
Image Credit: Catrice. Okay, so, Catrice Care in Colours Lip Balm in Wild Rebel isn’t major on TikTok…yet. It’s a hydrating, pigmented lip balm that looks good on every skin tone. And Amazon shoppers said, “I bought these to moisten my lips with a touch of color. I was amazed that even after it feels like it’s ‘rubbed off,’ the color is still there.”
Catrice Care in Colours Lip Balm in Wild Rebel$6
on Amazon.com
-
e.l.f. Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic
Image Credit: e.l.f. e.l.f.’s Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic is a tinted lip balm that comes in a variety of shades and features a heart-shaped core that moisturizes dry lips while simultaneously delivering a tint of sheer color and shine. It contains Vitamin E for optimal moisture, so you get both the deep berry color and smooth feel.
Dermatologist and TikToker Dr. Angelo showed fans the lipsticks side-by-side, showing how similar they are (with Elf being slightly darker)!
Pros:
-Moisturizing with Vitamin E
-Pigmented
-Long-lasting
-Super-close color match
Cons:
-Darker than Black Honey
-Not universal perfect shade
-Some don’t like the smell of the balm
e.l.f. Hydrating Core Lip Shine in Ecstatic$7
on Amazon.com
-
Burt’s Bees Lip Tint Balm in Red Dahlia
Image Credit: Burt’s Bees. Probably the most iconic lookalike is the Burt’s Bees Lip Tint Balm in Red Dahlia, which many claim is nearly identical to Black Honey. This tinted lip balm is both long-lasting and nourishing thanks to the shea butter; plus it’s buildable, meaning you can have little or more on for any type of look you wish.
One shopper said, “Bees Lip Balm in Red Dahlia is as close as I have been able to come in my quest for an equivalent…”
Pros:
-Less than $10 for two of them
-Lots of similar shades
-Long-lasting
-Hydrating
Cons:
-Not the most pigmented
-Can’t get a singular one on Amazon
Burt’s Bees Lip Tint Balm in Red Dahlia$9 for 2-Pack
-
e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry
Image Credit: e.l.f. e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry is a hydrating, glossy lipstick that contains Vitamin E for optimal moisture. It has a balmy formula and is super lightweight, so it’s perfect for chilled makeup or every day makeup looks.
TikToker @mynaimisaiko1 showed different lookalikes, highlighting how this one is, she believes, to be the closest lookalike of them all!
Pros:
-Moisturizing with Vitamin E
-Glossy
-Super-close color match
Cons:
-Sheer
-Lack of shade range
e.l.f. Sheer Slick Lipstick in Black Cherry$5
on Amazon.com
-
Labello BlackBerry Shine Lip Balm
Image Credit: Labello. Labello BlackBerry Shine Lip Balm is said to provide 24-hour moisture, along with a sleek, glossy purple-red tint to the lips like Black Honey. This shimmery, dermatologist-approved balm is also great for softening even the most cracked, chapped lips. So get that shine and care all in one!
TikToker @claudiafides shared all of the lookalikes she had, including the Labello one that was so close to Black Honey.
Pros:
-24 Hour moisture
-Glossy
-Dermatologist-approved
Cons:
-Sheer
-Not as many reviews
Labello BlackBerry Shine Lip Balm$5, originally $9
-
Revlon Super Lustrous Glass Shine Moisturizing Lipstick in Black Cherry
Image Credit: Revlon. The Revlon Super Lustrous Glass Shine Moisturizing Lipstick in Black Cherry is a dark, shimmery lipstick that is perfect for getting a glossy purple pout that smooths your lips. Not only does it have aloe and hyaluronic acid to ensure your lips are soft and supple, but the color is almost an exact match to Black Honey.
TikToker @glambbi showed fans how they compare side-by-side, in case you’re wondering!
Pros:
-Depending on what you want, it’s more pigmented than Black Honey
-Doesn’t feather or bleed
Cons:
-Depending on what you want, it’s darker than Black Honey, so it may not be universal like Black Honey is.
-More shimmery instead of glossy
Revlon Super Lustrous Glass Shine Moisturizing Lipstick in Black Cherry$7, originally $11
on Amazon.com
-
Honest Tinted Lip Balm in Plum Drop
Image Credit: Honest. The Honest Tinted Lip Balm in Plum Drop is a moisturizing, colorful lip balm that works with sensitive skin on your lips! It’s a vegan balm that nourishes your lips with the acai extracts and avocado oil. While it’s available in seven shades, the shade Plum Drop is a must for a Black Honey lookalike.
When TikToker @myglammelancholy compared the two, many noticed how similar the color and shine was! It’s not a perfect match, but it’s so darn close!
Pros:
-Same shine as Black Honey
-Ultra-nourishing for sensitive lips
-Vegan
-Moisturizing since it’s a lip balm
Cons:
-More cool-toned compared to Black Honey
-Less long-lasting than the lipstick
Honest Tinted Lip Balm in Plum Drop$9, originally $10
on Amazon.com
-
COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm in Bliss You Berry
Image Credit: COVERGIRL. CoverGirl’s Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm in Bliss You Berry is a tinted lip balm that instantly hydrates and moisturizes your mouth for a smooth, supple finish. Plus, CoverGirl’s Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm delivers a subtle, natural-looking shine with every application since it’s made with hyaluronic acid, and it’s designed to last up to 24 hours with color and hydration.
Plus, it’s recently gone viral for looking like an exact lookalike to Black Honey, and TikToker @_alyssa_lorraine_’s video proves that.
Pros:
-Nearly identical in shade and consistency to Black Honey
-Contains hyaluronic acid
-Known for being smoothing and long-lasting
Cons:
-Some shoppers say it’s more of a lipstick than a balm
CoverGirl Clean Fresh Tinted Lip Balm$5, originally $8 $7.99
on Amazon.com
